Having just recently experienced the wonder that is Burlington, Vermont's own Kahiki Moon, I was drawn to this website, which is devoted to the culture of tiki bars. It lists over 500 tiki bars worldwide and, as the site's name implies, rates them according to various attributes (decor, drink quality, food selection, etc.). I am pleased to report that Kahiki Moon in downtown Burlington is one of the very highest rated tiki bars in the world, according to the site:

Decor: 9.6
Drink Quality: 9
Drink Selection: 10
Food Quality: 10
Food Selection: 9.6
Mood: 10
Music: 9.2
Service: 9.4
Tikiness: 9.6
Tilt: 10
Vibe: 8.8

Overall rating: 9.6

via Boing Boing